https://netmaker.org logo
Title
g

glamorous-traffic-41474

11/11/2022, 2:41 PM
can a node access an egress network? So I have 3 nodes: netmaker "server", a netclient node at azure and a netclient node at home. my netclient node at home is configured as egress to my whole home network -> configured the ip range of my home lan range. my netclient node at azure cannot see my home network IPs when I try to ping some of them. No docker, pure linux.
q

quiet-continent-24852

11/11/2022, 2:46 PM
this sounds like a reasonable setup and has been done before. Which linux distro are you using on your home node?
g

glamorous-traffic-41474

11/11/2022, 2:47 PM
ubuntu server 22
q

quiet-continent-24852

11/11/2022, 2:47 PM
Okay, and have you taken note of the correct CIDR and interface name when creating the egress?
g

glamorous-traffic-41474

11/11/2022, 2:49 PM
Yes, I have a second network configured which uses the exact egress params and my external clients can access my home lan
but this second network seems to have problems
in this network I do not have an ingress, just an egress
would I need an ingress still?
q

quiet-continent-24852

11/11/2022, 2:49 PM
you should not
g

glamorous-traffic-41474

11/11/2022, 2:49 PM
ok
q

quiet-continent-24852

11/11/2022, 2:51 PM
your home node is on both networks and trying to egress the same lan on both?
g

glamorous-traffic-41474

11/11/2022, 2:51 PM
yes
q

quiet-continent-24852

11/11/2022, 2:52 PM
Okay thanks for the information, I'll have to look into if there is bug there or something. Is there any reason why you're separating the networks in that case?
g

glamorous-traffic-41474

11/11/2022, 2:55 PM
not really, I was just testing a second network before pushing it to my main network
trying some additional nodes before actually applying it to my main network
I will just move them to my main and remove the second network and see how it goes
thanks
q

quiet-continent-24852

11/11/2022, 2:56 PM
sounds good - please let me know if you see the same behavior on one network
g

glamorous-traffic-41474

11/11/2022, 3:13 PM
ok so I joined the node to my main network. On my main I have 3 nodes: netmaker server, my home node and now this 3rd node at azure. My home node can ping the netmaker node. The 3rd node can pint the netmaker node. But my home node cannot ping the 3rd node and 3rd node cannot ping my home node. Odd
my external clients can ping both: my home node and the 3rd node
I will try restarting all nodes, maybe the netmaker server is not propperly refreshing ..
q

quiet-continent-24852

11/11/2022, 3:18 PM
hmm idk that is odd, maybe you could try to relay your home node via your netmaker server in order to communicate with the azure one.. It should work without it since it's a public cloud, but not sure why without digging into it more
g

glamorous-traffic-41474

11/11/2022, 3:19 PM
yeah I will just stop now. I was planning to upgrade to latest version soon (whatever it is) so I will just do that and try again my whole setup. Thanks anyways for the help.