I am unable to get any client to connect

Question

I am unable to get any client to connect to my saas instance no handshake

jolly-london-20127 · Answer

please paste `journalctl fu netclient`

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

okay i think its a bug with netclient it is tring to connect to a netmaker domain that was previously used on the host eventhough i just used a join token from the new instance

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

on another host all looks normal ```May 20 13 31 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 31 54 restarting daemon May 20 13 31 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 31 54 adding addresses to netmaker interface May 20 13 31 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 31 54 Starting Proxy May 20 13 31 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 31 54 set nat info REMOVED 10 0 2 219 2074 51723 false double May 20 13 31 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 31 54 netclient message queue started for server 2dfc9992 7ac5 49e2 a68d 9b4a5b726d62 app prod netmaker io May 20 13 31 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 31 54 initialized endpoint detection on port 51723 May 20 13 31 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 31 54 mqtt connect handler May 20 13 32 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 32 54 collecting metrics for network checkmk May 20 13 32 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 32 54 published metrics for node checkmkrivercityitca May 20 13 33 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 33 54 collecting metrics for network checkmk May 20 13 33 54 checkmk rivercityit ca netclient 938 netclient 2023 05 20 13 33 54 published metrics for node checkmkrivercityitca```

jolly-london-20127 · Answer

are you still a part of the old server as well e g is this a second server you are joining

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

I left all networks then joined the new one i just reinstalled and that issue is gone but hosts still can t handshake

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

``` netclient 2023 05 20 20 01 41 adding addresses to netmaker interface netclient 2023 05 20 20 01 42 Starting Proxy netclient 2023 05 20 20 01 42 set nat info 172 245 133 173 172 245 133 173 51722 51722 false public netclient 2023 05 20 20 01 42 netclient message queue started for server 2dfc9992 7ac5 49e2 a68d 9b4a5b726d62 app prod netmaker io netclient 2023 05 20 20 01 42 initialized endpoint detection on port 51722 netclient 2023 05 20 20 01 42 mqtt connect handler netclient 2023 05 20 20 02 42 collecting metrics for network c center netclient 2023 05 20 20 02 42 published metrics for node abc ```

jolly-london-20127 · Answer

Output looks normal are there peers on the interface

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

yes there are

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

```endpoint 172 245 133 173 51821 allowed ips 10 100 2 2 32 transfer 0 B received 27 89 KiB sent persistent keepalive every 20 seconds```

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

same type of responce on other host

jolly-london-20127 · Answer

is the endpoint correct

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

yes

jolly-london-20127 · Answer

please post the peer section for this machine on the other host 172 245 133 173

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

``` endpoint 194 163 47 143 51821 allowed ips 10 100 2 1 32 transfer 0 B received 111 00 KiB sent persistent keepalive every 20 seconds```

jolly-london-20127 · Answer

and that endpoint is also correct

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

yes

jolly-london-20127 · Answer

strange no idea why that would be an issue then it looks fine

jolly-london-20127 · Answer

have you tested self hosted as well

boundless-ability-97383 · Answer

i have not

jolly-london-20127 · Answer

ok I d like to take a look with you when you have the time